Food For Thought

Facing reality.......

A coup d’état is usually brought about by people who are convinced that they cannot acquire power through democratic means and / or those whose vital interests are mightily threatened without power .

Thursday, June 4, 2009

Post Election

Following the Parliamentary Elections, many have asked me about the outcome, both regarding the constituency I contested in, and in more general terms, nationally. I have not commented on either, other than to say that with regard to my own campaign, that I accept the decision of the public.

The first question asked from me by the media was of course, whether the result of the election meant that my political career was over. I was asked the same question over and over again following the Presidential Elections. I sometimes mull over what might happen to a nation if everyone who loses an election left the political stage. How many more politicians would be forthcoming?

The outcome of any election simply means that the public decided in a particular way at that point in time. They are at complete liberty to change their minds and go 180 in the next election. This is more so in parliamentary elections. But it seems to me that for some reason, there are a number of ‘powerful’ people who are rather anxiously waiting for me to declare that I have quit politics.

There is one myth which has been created that in 2005 I was elected to the Majlis by MDP, and therefore, my failure to secure the seat this time was because I left MDP. The wisdom goes on to say I should rejoin MDP to ensure centre stage in the political arena. The fact however is, that I got elected to the Majlis long before political parties became a reality in the Maldives. Selective amnesia, I suppose.

But there is one important question to be addressed in this regard. Do I want to be elected to the Majlis so badly, that I would sell my soul to the devil? If I seek election, why do I seek it? Is it for personal fame and gain, or to work towards achieving certain national goals while still retaining my morality and principles? Would I become part of a farce simply to declare that I am an MP?

There are two paths to the Majlis. One is to see which way the tide is turning, get on the band-wagon which is most likely to win, and sail through. That way, you could be changing loyalties every other day. But the question then is, what do you hope to achieve out of it? The second way is to feel a lot of passion for what you believe in with regard to your nation, convince enough people that what you are trying to do is good for the nation, and get a mandate from those people to act on their behalf in making national decisions. I chose the second path in 2004 and 2005 and again in 2008 and 2009. I succeeded in 2004 and 2005; but I failed in 2008 and 2009.

I failed to convince enough people of Machangolhi Uthuru constituency that the Majlis should be a place which focuses on the national interest rather than be an arena for two individuals to feed their egos via proxies and in the process destroy the nation. I tried, but I failed. Now that I have failed, I must accept the following fact.

The fact is, that the majority of Maldivian people do not want democracy or the rule of law. They just want to empower individuals who will look after their personal interests, and a government which will provide personal opportunities for them at the cost of their neighbour’s opportunities. Feudalism at its best. This is the harsh reality. Corrupt politicians can only succeed in a nation of corrupt or apathetic voters.

The question for me, then is, am I willing to ‘go with the tide’ to win political power? No, Thank you.

22 comments:

  1. I agree with your point that a lose in an election is not necessarily a message to leave the plat forms of politics. True, and indeed very true. I do appreciate the contribution of Mr. Ibra in the Maldivian politics. No one, I think with a honest heart will reject the reality that Mr. Ibra did contribute a lot to the politics of the country and the change that our country is going through, specially via Majlis. Thank you.
    Yet, I do have something to add too. I do not think that majority of the people in this country "do not want democracy or the rule of law." Let me put it in a simple way. The people saying NO to Mr. Ibra in no way means they said No to law and order or democracy.
    Mr. Ibra. My point is very simple. You are one of the very important agents of change to democracy in our country. I wholeheartedly believe that and thank you for that as a child of the nation. I believe your an agent of change, but I don't believe your the "sole" agent of the change.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Ibra, as one of our mutual friends told me yesterday, I think the problem is that, at this particular moment in time, Maldivian people are in the 'mood' for 'activist' politics. No wonder Reeko Moosa (I'm confounded that he is even MDP's parliamentary group leader, damn it!) and Mariya are still popular. I believe that during this first term of Anni (and if he wins a second term, during the second term as well), this 'activist' political atmosphere will prevail.

    It is only after that, when activism politics subsides, will Maldivians brace themselves ready for 'intellectual' politics, which belongs to the arena of smart, diplomatic and intellectual people like you, Kutti Nasheed, Ilyas Labib, Alhan Fahmy, Eva Abdulla, Mahloof and Rozaina.

    The question is, after 5 or 10 years while this younger group will still be around energetically pursuing politics, whether Kutti and you will still have the mood to pursue politics with the same energy as you two do now. If so, then I believe you will become prominent again when that time of 'intellectual politics' come. So perhaps, at this time, what you can do is pursue social work, and bide your time until the opportunity presents itself again :) Cheers.

    ReplyDelete
  3. "The fact however is, that I got elected to the Majlis long before political parties became a reality in the Maldives" this is a carefully crafted sentence most likely for your own self-deception. MDP was working in exile at that time, and you were endorsed by MDP and that's the only reason you got elected at that point.

    Ibra your elitist attitude has failed you, if you want to win, you have to change 180, not the people! If you expect the people to do a 180, you are just being too ignorant and arrogant. Change you can!

    Ibra2008 -----> Ibbe2013 :)

    Nahidha

    ReplyDelete
  4. Ibra,
    I dont agree with you when you say that MDP did not exist when you were elected. Yes MDP may not have been registered, but it did exist, and you were associated with MDP. Either you want to accept it or not, you did receive MDP supporters votes and thats one major reason why you got elected. The proof is, since you left MDP you have contested in 2 elections, and failed badly both times. Yes you shouldn't quit politics, but I believe its time for you to accept that something you are doing is not right or acceptable to the people of Maldives. Therefore its time for you to change 180 degrees! Soften down a bit! Politics isnt only about pushing your own beliefs no-matter-what! Its also about following your constituency and their dreams and beliefs.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Divehin vaanee dhivehinnah. including u (not me anymore) ibra. pathetic sea creatures after all u all r. :)

    ReplyDelete
  6. "Now that I have failed, I must accept the following fact. The fact is, that the majority of Maldivian people do not want democracy or the rule of law."

    LOL. You are priceless Ibra!

    ReplyDelete
  7. @Alif Laam Gaaf, Nahidha & Anonymous (Jun 5, 12:14):

    As many people often do, you have put a spin on what I said. I never said that the fact that I did not get elected meant Maldivians did not want democracy or rule of law.

    What I said was I failed to convince the people of those beliefs. Whether I get elected or not is a different issue. If I convinced them of those things that I stand for, they would have voted for me. So I failed in CONVINCING them.

    If you compare what the winner, Mariya, said to the people and what I said to the people, it is very clear what the people chose. Mariya and I, are both insignificant as individuals.

    If you compare what I said, and the other 5 candidates said in the Presidential elections, it is very clear what the people chose.

    The people will ultimately live by what they chose. That is all that I said.

    Nahidha, what you have said is exactly the anti-thesis of what I said. I said that I would want to get elected to pursue a certain STATED political agenda. What you are saying is that I should change my views to suit the voting public SO that I get elected...to do what? How can I pretend to be what they want before I get elected, and then do as I please? If I get elected by saying that I stand for what they want, then I should do what they want. But the fact is, I can't do what they want right now, because they don't want what I believe. I will simply have to wait until their mindset is in tune with what I believe.

    You see, Nahidha, winning a seat in the Majlis is not all that important for me if I don't have the mandate to carry out what I believe. Obviously you subscribe for opportunism, while I do not. Let us agree to differ on that particular world-view.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Dear Ibra
    First sorry for my broken eglish.Hope you will what i have written.Its nice getting a new article to read.I regularly visit your blog..We appreciate what you have done and support your policies.We really miss you and sad knowing we could not hear your voice from Parliament.But belive thats the life, thats politics,we have to learn to live even in terrible time of the life.wE always want to know your view about certain issues.So please share with us what you see abou the issues
    1.Kutti Nasheed proposed ammendments a.50%salary cut to mps b.to get approval from the national defence committee in the parlaiment before dismissal of heads of police and defence and senior menbers of the two institutions.
    2.Thaa menber Riyaz Rasheed(hassan saeed party) bill to get majilis approval of state ministers and deputy ministers.
    3.your view about the following sentence.This is what Kutti NASHEED has said in his blog.This shows his ego and rudness.No one has absloute power.Allah knows everthing well.Almight Allah is most powerful.He may loose his seat tomorrow.no body knows.We dont have to say such sentiments to our brothers and sisters.


    "Yet, Suood’s drawbacks, when weighed on a fair balance, was no comparison to the dirty tricks played by Mohamed Shihab, as the erstwhile speaker of parliament. How he rolled up the institution and presented it to the president in exchange for a promise of reward – the post of Home Affairs Minister couldn’t be ignored. If he were not to get the Home Affairs job, he would have been dead meat politically. There was no constituency in the country that would return him to parliament. His performance in parliament was outrageously ridiculous, or should I say, ridiculously outrageous." Alifuthaa

    ReplyDelete
  9. Dearest Ibra,

    You have the right to be angry and wounded, if you were not you would not be a man who has loved his people so much. Only he who has loved Dhivehi Raaj can actually be so hurt by this shallowness... Ibra, through out all this, I am hurting and angry too. I feel, frightened, angry and helpless against corruption and gangsterism and corruption, and I know that only a man of peace and integrity such as yourself could feel so wounded by all of this for as deep as reason as you feel... I know you don't care about the privileges of parliament, the prestige, I know you are only wounded that you cannot fight evil and heal the people...You have every right to be angry...

    I am reminded of one of the key points of J.S. Mill's On Liberty. Truth and goodness is not always that which is accepted by the majority,,, true freedom, liberating knowledge is often rejected by the masses, it is anti-democratic... I know you know this...but it is important to reflect right now on this... In the end, you must believe your self gains eternal power by being rejected for truth, as truth is all that is eternal,,,what is untrue dies no matter how many people follow it...

    What would have happened if Galilleo gave up on his pursuit of truth if he bowed down and served the will of the majority who thought he was against religion.... The path of truth and morality is a lonely struggle but you are rich for being strong enough to follow it...

    All the best

    Abdul-Rahman

    ReplyDelete
  10. My dear Ibra,

    I agree with Nahidha. If you accept people to listen to your 'stated' agenda, you should also be a little bit less stubborn enough to accept that you could be a little bit wrong sometimes. Not all the times. You are the greatest and you know everything.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Ibra,
    Does it ever cross your mind that people are not always perfect and you may also have flaws and faults? You may also need to change???!!

    ReplyDelete
  12. Ibra,
    You want to do it your way or never? So you want to wait till your constituency changes their minds and follow you??!? Sounds a bit strange! Do you think you are always right on everything and everybody else is wrong??

    ReplyDelete
  13. Ibra...was looking forward for this...i aint a supporter of you...and didnt vote for you in both elections.....

    but always knew you could talk...and yeah i think this is very much the case for most of the people....they dnt denounce you bt they jst seem to have a better option!

    I dnt think its the end of the world for you...you jst lost two elections in 6 mnths...and yeah lost it very badly!!

    Presidential elections, u jus had no chance....u chose a shit running mate...trying to follow in america's john mccain...to get those women voters...wht u didn understnd was this is Maldives and we all being Musilims....it will take us time to get thr....and also no one was toking about you...Ur campaign manager...hope he's fired already!!

    n then came parliament elections....m guesing u thote u had the upper hand on this....as uve worked hard and did a lot of work in parliament....and as u wr contesting a seat in Male', u mus hv thote tht people would be more aware and vote U cos u tok rite and work hard....bt NOOO....they wr even more clever!!!they knew aslong as ur party and supporters wudnt get a majority!!it was worthless....soo they jst chose between mdp and drp..(jst like the guys in jail voted for other candidates in presidential elections)..i mean luk@the no. of votes rauna(drp) candidate got?she didn even run a campaign but got like 300 votes...soo i gues u knw wht m saying...

    Soo, i dunno wht2say mayn...just sumthin about social liberal party is not right..we(the people) view it in the same way as we do (for fageerukan nahthaalhaa party).m serious mayn....we dnt take ur party seriously nt at all...u guys are neva on the news....neva eva...hassan saeed and ppl are always thr....weneva they hv a party rally...bt u, neva to be seen....

    and yeah....i think this wasnt the post we were expecting from u....bt ofcos i understnd the frustration and the dissapointment u mus be having towards the Maldivian general public...bt i was lukin forward for sumthin more positive as u did take time to relax and think straight b4 u got this post in....bt i think by U thinking thrs nuin more to loose and jst go on showing ur dissapointment toweards...thegeneralpublic wudnt help....its a very thin line ...so a lot cud change...

    i guessthe only way u cud be visiblein politics is make a coalition or sumim wit a proper party....and u go and adress them in rallies and try to get the word out.....hiding atur house dosnt help....be positive....

    its a very thin line....

    ReplyDelete
  14. @Abdul Rahman :
    Drop me an email sometime.

    @Anonymouses urging me to "change" :
    What exactly do you want me to change into, or do differently? As to being right or wrong...in most democracies the majority is often wrong and the minority is often right...it just takes the majority a little bit longer to realize what is right. If the majority was always right, the world wouldn't be in this dismal state. But still, if majority view was not allowed to prevail, we would have societies which are totally haywire. So the minority just has to put up with the majority.

    @ Anonymous with the deep analysis :

    The truth is often bitter, isn't it? The difference between you and I is that I know when to stop and retreat, you don't. Why do you assume that I particularly WANT to be "visible"? As you yourself stated, I worked hard, I did what was right. But in your book, the public is cleverer than I am because they are smart enough to reject what is right and take on what is not right....and you are urging me to be part of that? I can't fathom that logic, I'm afraid. A "proper" party? Pray, tell me what kind of a creature is that?

    ReplyDelete
  15. With this kind of mindset.. that the majority is mostly wrong.. and that the minority is right.. how do you intend to win an election in the future?

    ReplyDelete
  16. @Anonymous (Jun 6, 8:29 pm) :

    If I wanted that badly to win an election, I suppose I could try letting go of what is right and join those in the wrong. I would then be part of the majority, wouldn't I?

    But you and I both know that the results of the last two elections were not based on what was right or wrong. And you and I both know why unjustified, irrational comments are appearing on this blog. But I am afraid, you have two years at the most for that kind of idiocy to prevail. As Abdul-Rahman pointed out above, ultimately the truth will prevail. The sad part is, what might happen while the truth is being established.

    ReplyDelete
  17. hey ibra...

    wht are u referin to wen u say tht in TWO years time???whts gona happen in two years???


    (Anonymous with deep analysis)

    ReplyDelete
  18. Anonymous, I think Ibra is talking about Shula Shiraz there.

    ReplyDelete
  19. yeah!!!bt if it is shula shirax...then DRP cums to power!!!soo all of a sudden they are clean??

    ReplyDelete
  20. haha...n yeah ibra u've said "that i know wen to stop and retreat, you dont!"

    All i have to stay is if u knew...u wudn hav contested in the parliamentry elections!!!haha...

    ReplyDelete
  21. Dear Ibra
    I would have liked you to win and have people like you who thinks analytically and strategically at the Majlis. Also becaues when you talk you make an impression and people do listen. But unfortunately this is not to be.
    I would now like to see you, if the Majlis decides to review the Commissions, as heading the Human Rights Commission, because you'll be able to do a lot of good as a liberal minded person.
    best regards

    ReplyDelete
  22. Ibra,
    I feel you claim that no country has a democracy.
    Every country elects MPs from political parties who have an agenda for the country.
    If you call MPs from a party a mere PROXY, then every country has proxies like that...
    Surely this statement in very wrong and is just a pathetic claim to misguide the people of Maldives.
    We dont just want the RULE OF LAW, we also want development, policies etc...
    Nobody can rule against LAW, so just by saying rule of law means that you have nothing else to offer.

    ReplyDelete