Food For Thought

Facing reality.......

A coup d’état is usually brought about by people who are convinced that they cannot acquire power through democratic means and / or those whose vital interests are mightily threatened without power .

Saturday, August 16, 2008

Twenty First Century Rannamari

When the Reform Movement started in earnest in 2004, it was clear that the Presidency of Qayyoom, or Qayyoom himself was the main obstruction for Maldivians to achieve their dreams of a fulfilling life. Seemingly he held all the power. He was perceived to be all powerful, and hence it was very easy to assume, and even easier to convince people, that the panacea to all our troubles was to remove him from office.

Ironically, the very fact that Qayyoom held all this power was also the basis for his downfall. Those around him had been abusing public office for years, and by and large, Qayyoom had been taking the blame for all abuses in front of the public. The theory was, I think, that there would never be a day when he would be held accountable for anything. Those abusing public office, and those enjoying his patronage would always be there to “cushion” the impact. As a result, Qayyoom was seen by many to be the source of all troubles, and removing him from office would, by default, solve our problems, just like that. To be fair, the poor guy most probably did not know what was happening within his government half the time. That is not say that his “not knowing” absolves him from anything. It was his business TO know, and it is a pretty lame excuse as an answer for his incompetency. Nevertheless, the end game has shown that none of his cronies are coming to his rescue now, and he is being dropped like a hot potato very quickly. Lessons to be learnt here for all “Presidential Hopefuls”!

Sometimes you feel sorry for the fellow when all those people who benefitted from his illegitimate rule, received undue favours from him to build up multi-million dollar empires, filled high posts in his government when they had no right to, just turn around and start crying “foul” on him. Sometimes I wonder what he thinks to himself these days. Must be bitter feelings, he has, these days. But I suppose he could take some comfort in the fact that there still are people like us, who have at least been consistent in our criticisms of the way he governs.

What is significant in our ponderings on the “bring down Qayyoom panacea” is that, even after the might of Qayyoom has been brought down, there are some who still want to cultivate and promote the idea that Qayyoom is still all powerful, and that the primary thing is to get him out of office. For those people, even forgoing the processes required to hold a free and fair election, giving out and receiving bribes, using gang violence, distributing joints and “pieces” can be justified on the ground that all this is for the single objective of “bringing down Qayyoom”. Even if it means taking the nation out of Qayyoom’s hands and putting it in the hands of a cartel of corrupt and greedy businessmen or in the hands of one who doesn’t even have a notion of what rule of law is about.

The way I see it, the very existence of certain schools of thought can only be justified with the existence of a real or perceived all powerful Qayyoom. Hence this myth has to be cultivated carefully to justify the actions necessary to sustain these schools of thought, and their place in Maldivian politics. Isn’t it a contradiction itself, that the very existence of those trying to bring down Qayyoom is so dependant on Qayyoom himself? Talk about symbiotic relationships!

The reality is that Qayyoom’s power has been stripped off him now. All the props holding up the regime have crumbled away. The opportunists are now frantically looking for another “Qayyoom” to prop up so that they can be all important in the process. Question is, will the public see this and understand this in time?

I say, forget Qayyoom now. Focus on the future. Take charge of our own lives and destinies. Let us vow to ourselves, that never again will we allow others to dictate to us. We have an excellent constitution in place now, a constitution which truly lets us define our futures. Let us be thoughtful in how we exercise our newly acquired liberties and freedoms.

One unanswered question in Maldivian folklore has been whether there ever really was a Rannamari, or was it an illusion created by the Sultan to take the rap for all the virgins he raped and killed? We can breathe easy when all Rannamaris have been finally put to rest.

30 comments:

  1. I see you have an awfully good sense of humour! You'll do a good president, keep posting!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Suppose you win the elections..........what will become of the helpless old fart? will he be subject to banishment? I really feel that those who worked beside him and benifited from maumoon's policies and administration "illegally" must be subject to the fraction that's worth of golhaaboa's criminal acts against the country, its people, the administration and humanity!

    ReplyDelete
  3. hey... i'm not sympathizing with the man...i'm just being fair

    ReplyDelete
  4. Anonymous:
    Not an easy decision, I admit. But if we are to forge a better future, we have to let go of the past at some point. Ours is a small, closely knit society. Should we subject our society to further pain, or is it better to put the past behind us and go on with life. God knows we will have plenty to do once we have a new government.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I see that in all your writings you have tried to project yourself as the man behind all the changes that we see today or is it my misinterpretation? I'm not denying the fact that you've worked hard to bring the changes but I feel that a lot of people are involved in bringing the benifits of the new constitution. Wouldn't it be more counter productive if you were to explain the difficulties you faced then and now in bringing the changes you desire for the people and also about the other politicians, other than Gayoom who seem to be obstructing your work for the people. Or is it jusy Gayoom alone who's standing in your way of serving the people.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi Ibra,

    Your articles are good, both in content and presentation. But like you said in the education policy launching, I'm amongst the 95% of people who failed in English. So my vocabulary isn't as good as yours. I want to effortlessly digest your ideas cos' I believe they are good. And I want to reduce my dictionary referring time as well.

    You have my full support.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Anonymous:
    Yes, it is a misinterpretation. How can one person, single handedly bring the change that we are seeing today? I am just trying to share my thoughts about the process. I have done my bit, and so have many other people. Every effort by every person had a crucial role. Some up front and some behind the scenes. But I do get irritated when some people speak like it was all the work of one person or one particular political party or just the government or activists or politicians. No one person or group of people can claim the total credit of what has happened.

    No, it isn't just Qayyoom who stands in the way of reform, and that was not what I intended to say. I was trying to capture a PERCEPTION that some were trying to create.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Away from home, the cyberspace has become a necessity these days to find out the happenings in Maldives, and it is good to hear from a politician in this amazing universe!
    It is good to see that politicians are not all abt political rhetorics thesedays. Good to see your human side, normal and down to earth side. Guess a new bread of politicians springing up, no longer banishing themselves 5 feet above the ground, where a normal person can only see his feet when standing up!! Good to see that you are reachable and want to reach out!!
    Now Im not too big on commenting, but just could not stop wondering... I took the meaning from your business elite comment, that you were refering to the republicans but I have yet to figure out who the other person is, Hassan, Anni?? ( The person with no idea what rule of law is all abt) Now i might be taking the wrong meaning, and you had no person particular in mind, but if would be good to know directly from you, what you think of your challengers, move the focus away from your biggest challenge gayoom a lil!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Criticizing Qayoom and writing about his failures, influences, corruption etc will not fetch you the support you need. You need to invest your time educating the public about your policies. Im hoping you will write soon about your education policy.

    We are desperately in need of a 'Twenty First Century' President.

    =maldivian student in UK=

    ReplyDelete
  10. "Isn’t it a contradiction itself, that the very existence of those trying to bring down Qayyoom is so dependant on Qayyoom himself?"

    if u wud b kind enough to explain what you ment there?

    ReplyDelete
  11. i'm just curious if ibra has any connections with endherimaage

    ReplyDelete
  12. u know you and qasim are the spoilers who prevented nomination of a single candidate from opposition. does maumoon pay you for this great contribution by you to his campainge.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Maldivian student in UK:
    The Education policy has ben launched on Sunday night, and we are elaborating on the details on various radio/tv programmes. Details will also be published on the campaign website www.ibra2008.com soon.

    In the meantime, the speech I gave in the launching, outlining general directions is also now available on the website.

    I would like to keep the blog mainly focussed on my personal thoughts relating to various aspects of the reform process.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Anonymous:

    "Isn’t it a contradiction itself, that the very existence of those trying to bring down Qayyoom is so dependant on Qayyoom himself?"

    What I meant is, that there are many elements in the reform process who keep on claiming that there only objective is to bring down Qayyoom. Therefore, if Qayyoom is not there, then those people have nothing more to contribute to the nation, and there work is finished.

    I really belive that even though Qayyoom is still President, he does not have the sweeping powers he had before. So therefore, in a sense, "Qayyoom is now gone", and what we see now is a shell of what he represented.

    Nevertheless, there are still some people who keep on talking about "bringing down" Qayyoom, when in reality, there is no Qayyoom to bring down anymore! But if they admit it, then they have to justify their candidacies etcetera through a vision they have for the country, and established credibility to realise the vision, both of which they lack.

    Hence, to justify their actions, they still maintain the illusion of the all powerful Qayyoom, because the moment they admit that Qayyoom is no longer all powerful, their own position in the political arena will be questioned. Hence their own existence is dependant on the existence of the all powerful Qayyoom itself. Does this make sense?

    ReplyDelete
  15. Dear Anonymous,

    Wake up!!! It was never a question of nominating a single candidate but choosing "THE" single candidate from the opposition.

    It was plot by the "three musketeers" to get the reform movement to back their candidate - as they did not have the back bone to attempt at forming a political party.

    I thank all those, whether it is Ibra, Qasim, Umar or Anni, who blocked this.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Dear Ibra,
    Thank you very much for taking some time to reply to the comment I made. There are very few Maldivian politicians with a VISION and im sure you are one of them.

    Change We Can Change We Shall

    Maldivian student in UK

    ReplyDelete
  17. Hi Ibra,
    Haven't read the article however would like suggest one of my own concern regarding the education policy. I'm happy with it however, would like to add few. I'm writing here cos I couldn't find any other way to contact.

    My suggestion: I think we need to include proper arts education in the school education system. Music and drama. Perhaps this will produce youth who will meet the entry requirements of Degree programs hence they can continue their professional education in those paths. Not all students are good in Chemistry, Physics, Biology, History, Geography etc.. We perhaps not only need lawyer, doctors, teachers etc.. This will in my opinion help reduce unemployment in the future. We also need to formulate social and cultural policies for the youth. This will in my opinion reduce the crime as well.

    I'm talking about a plan that we will only be able to see the fruits after a decade. An experience that you and I have seen a bit in our school days in Majeediyya.

    A musician who has served you.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Hi Ibra,

    Just would like to share some thoughts with you regarding the Armed Forces Law. I believe it should be amended to include the following changes:

    - Propose a fixed term of 3 years for the Chief of Defence Force. This would help ensure dominance of that post by a single individual and ensure a steady turnover of command on a regular basis.

    - Exempt the Chief of Defence Force from the compulsory retirement age rule (in the Armed Forces Law). This would ensure once appointed the person has full 3 years to carry out his duties. Otherwise we might be faced with a Chiefs of Defence who might have to step down within a year of appointment to the post.

    - Set that the Chief of Defence Force position has to be appointed in consultation with the parliament. Following the same trend as with those of MMA Governor, Prosecutor General etc. This is to ensure that the position is protected from politically motivated appointments.

    As a member of parliament I hope you would consider these points. Also would be great if you could respond here with what you feel about these points I suggested.

    Dhivehi Dhariyeh - Gaumee Hidhumathuga

    ReplyDelete
  19. Hi Mr. Ibrahim Ismail,

    I am not any pro-party activist or a member. I was also a Journalist. still, I too update my knowledge of news from Maldives and different parts of the world.

    As we all know that you are having a campaign site, hope it’s doing something for our nation’s - good. You see, media is a platform we tell the world about our country and what happens here.

    Our country is dependant on Tourism, Mr. Ibra. Every one knows that, what do you think will happen to this economy if you give the wrong idea in media to the possible tourists who are to make a decision among many countries to select our country as their tourist destinations.

    Like most of the Maldivians now a days, me and some of my colleagues - we also have International friends and lived around them enough to see somethings ourselves. Most of the love-birds, couples and families do a lot of research before they select 'a place' to enjoy their holidays. They spend months saving money for their vacations. In these periods, they spend most of their free time searching for information on possible tourist destinations. What do you think will happen when they see negative headlines from the safest country '' Maldives'' in the Google search? Did you know, how devastated the reputation of Maldives has become, which was once considered as one of the safest in the world until you politiains. I remember seeing a make-up women in BBC, seems she thought she did great on a BBC show. Have you heard any thing about the relevance of first impression?


    Mr. Ibra, among so many of your talks, ill illustrate one. You’ve been quoted saying that Maldives is the top of world’s worst drug addict list. How dare you? Where is your fore seeing? Did you research on tourism, did you research on Drug trafficking, and Addiction rates before you opened you experienced self. Where does Cambodia, Mexico rank on your drug list.

    Would you like to take your loved - family to a place like Columbia, Mexico or recent addition on top drug trafficking countries - Afganistan for vacation? So don’t make the world think like Maldives is some place like that, or close to anything like that.


    I know Maldivian media is run by Maldivians. It is everyone's responsibility to protect our country, at all expects. Among all, ‘‘you’’ have been quoted saying “I was the ONLY person doing this good thing, or that good thing for this country''
    I think, a man of your dedication to the country and selected by respective 3000 people as their voice, should be careful in saying things in the first hand. Media writes what its politicians say.

    As most people know, you have been in the Journalism field for most of your life and been seen quoting only you have made the constitution in some of your campaign speeches., I guess you, amongst all should know how young and naïve the Maldivian media is, precisely for what the new constitution has to offer.

    As you are contesting for our leader and President, I would like to tell you that the person as our president has to have the talent to steer us in the best direction for the country.
    I would like to ask – Mr. Ibra Are you steering atleast a small community of Journalism of Maldives in a manner to do good to our country.

    Well, I don’t see it. Infact Journalism is a small Fraction of the Maldivian population.

    Mr. Ibra, if you have a problem with the current president, well, settle it with him, without hurting the country. Maldives doesn’t have a stage backed with Military or Economical Dominance like in America. So please keep that in Mind. Whatever you do, Don’t thwart our tourists or make any one or nation hate our country, in your fight for you to become president.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Anonymous (on Arts Education):
    It's good to see people commenting on this blog focussing on constructive ideas and issues.

    Yes, Arts education has to be strengthened immensely. It is almost non-existent in the curriculum. I will be expanding on changes in the curriculum that I focus on, and Arts Education will feature strongly in it.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Anonymous (on armed forces):

    The suggestions you made are certainly valid and worth serious consideration. However, It is a bit difficult to respond to those suggestions off-hand. My knowledge of the military is very limited, to say the least. There is no proper avenue for me to really engage in discussing these things with senior officers in the military who are better equipped to advise me on these issues. But I must say that those issues must be resolved, and I will certainly do my best to do so.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Anonymous (on tourism) :

    I am sorry you are quite misinformed on a number of things. Let me put some of those things straight, first.

    I am not a Journalist at all, I am an academic-turned-activist-turned-politician. I never said that I alone revised the constitution or that I am the only person working for reform (refer to an earlier reply to a comment on this Post); quite the contrary. I guess you also have been caught on the media spin on me regarding these things.

    I dare to say what I say, because this is my country as well. You and I might differ on what is good for the nation. You think violation of human rights, subjugation of the people, protection and racketeering in drugs and the underground should be "hidden and unexposed" because it might steer a few "love-birds" away from our "beautiful beaches"? Sorry Sir/Madam, I don't agree.

    I have my stats. Do you have yours? Compare per capita GDP being spent on drugs in the Maldives to those of other countries. Compare proportion of youth engaged in drug abuse in the Maldives to the same statistic in counrties like Columbia. Not only is first impression important, but so is not displaying ignorance.

    Whatever I said, I believe in it, and I can justify it. The beauty of democracy and pluralism is that both yours and my views (in this case diametrically opposed) have a place in society. Let us just see which prevails.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Thanks for the reply on the Armed Forces Law issue. In your capacity as a lawmaker if you wish to obtain professional advise on military affairs the best choice is Brigadier Moosa Jaleel.

    I take comfort in knowing that I have brought this issue to your knowledge and your assurance to work on it. Thanks for providing us this opportunity.

    Dhivehi Dhariyeh - Gaumee Hidhumathuga

    ReplyDelete
  24. Anonymous - On tourism

    I just had to say something abt this idea that somehow opening up our media, making it independent from talking 24/7 abt our beloved president, and his condolences and his larger than life speaches, is somehow adversely affecting tourism in our nation. No it is not! Look at the statistics, Maldivian tourist arrivals have largely been untouched by the political upheaval it has gone through. The last 6 years have seen it constantly increasing with slight adverse effects from the Asian Tsunami, or the SARS outbreak. Maybe the effects of the political upheaval is yet to show, or maybe there is no or just a lil adverse effect if at all!!

    As you have mentioned, tourists research before making there way to a destination, a destination as expensive and exclusive as Maldives, and if the potential tourist do there homework well theyd know that they are not going to stay in a Concrete Jungle( Thatd be Male') but in secluded beaches, in separate islands.

    NOW, no tourist in there right mind would compare a Columbia( columbia is actually one of the few destinations in South America where they are seeing an increase in arrivals) Afghanistan etc etc. Afghanistan is a war torn country, and Columbians are known to be at war with the drug cartels and the rebels!! Maybe you misunderstood, maldives is NOT a drug producer, it is a Drug Importer, and majority of its youth are addicts, but there is NO armed war against drug cartels or the likes of them, nor has there been any media portrayals as such.
    As ibra has pointed out, as a youth of this country, i myself know that the drug epidemic in our country is far beyond the picture so conveniently painted by the regime in charge. I am pretty sure that almost 70% of maldivian youth between 17 to 25 have or will atleast experiment with drugs, and that is the truth, the question is do we hide it? Pretend that nothing is wrong?? I dont quite get it!

    ReplyDelete
  25. for me as a man of ideas you seem to have all the "right" things to say. When it comes to accepting you to be my/our leader in waiting you seem unable to demonstrate the basic premise of a consolidated democratic structure behind your rhetoric.

    Your opposite(idea)/parallel(structural) seems to be Gasim and the Republicans.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Anonymous (democratic structure):

    Would you care to elaborate on your perception of a "democratic structure"?

    I believe that I have always built my rhetoric on my beliefs (ideas) and matched my rhetoric with tangible action. I would be interested to know of any solid evidence you have to the contrary.

    I feel a bit nauseous to read myself drawn in parallel to Qasim.

    ReplyDelete
  27. I gues you didnt do your home work. what i am telling ibra is not to make simple things bigger, for the reason he has a campaign to win, like shaheed or some as such. i asked ibra to publish his stats. i dont see it yet


    Also, like I said, Amomg news Bad things tend to spread. so its better not make links for them(bad news) to spread unless their is some thing very important.

    May be you hate maumoon. I dont hate anyone. who ever you hate, while express your or ibra's hate, please dont invovle it with the country's fragile life.

    now do you understand. before writing something think deep into it, in a balanced manner without favoring or hating anyone persnally.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Dear Anonymous,

    This is hilarious. You want someone running for president to hide the truth about Maldives. This is the problem. People like you trying to portray something else. Is that the ethics taught as a journalist. shame on you.

    Ibra, we need someone like you to tell the truth as is. It's not ok to deceive the tourists. I wonder if anonymous has ever heard something called "globalization". We can't hide anything anymore. UN or some other agency will have this info published somewhere on the internet. And as you say these tourists when they are doing their research rely on these international bodies a lot more than a few Maldivian politicians. So wake up. Be a true journalist and expose the truth.

    Ibra, you are the only one who tells the truth as is. this might keep some voters away. but don't worry there are more of us who have the stomach to hear it. Keep going. Tell the truth. Insha Allah "Change we can, Change we shall". Amen

    ReplyDelete
  29. http://naduha.blogspot.com/2008/09/we-dont-need-rannamaari-to-rule-our.html

    ReplyDelete
  30. I am the anony who asked for an explanation. Thank you for the response. Same thinking here with minor disagreements. How ever u still haven't convinced me why i should give my vote to you. I need more from u. I need more explanations on the policies you are comming up with. Perhaps the maldivian media do not know to ask the right questions. I would like you to explain your health policies as soon as possible. Thank you.

    ReplyDelete